Lindsay Mitchell looks at Social Welfare Reform
in New Zealand and Overseas
ph/fx 04 562 7944
mob 021 132 5968
National's Welfare Reform Proposals Don't go far Enough

Sunday, August 14, 2011

The welfare reform proposals that relate to young people on benefits announced today don't go far enough, welfare commentator Lindsay Mitchell said today.

"Allowing the Ministry of Education and the Ministry of Social Development to share information about school leavers going on welfare should never have been stopped in the first place. "

"Attaching obligations and  money management regimes to benefits received by 16 and 17 year-olds, and 18 year-old sole parents, is an improvement on the status quo.  However, many single parents enter the benefit system older than 18 still without the maturity or wherewithal to raise a child. Which begs the question, why draw an arbitrary line at 18?"

"The new message being sent is, if you go on the DPB at 19 you won't get hassled. "

"Today's announcement is a good start but doesn't go nearly far enough. Not only is it vital that existing  teen parents are required and supported to continue their own education or training, but that more potential sole parents are discouraged from choosing or defaulting to the benefit lifestyle."

"Strict time limits across all ages would act as such a deterrent."

"If the government is serious about reducing New Zealand's very high teenage birthrate and the associated deprivation, it should  promise an end to 16-17 year-old eligibility, and time limits - with some exemptions - extended to all others." 

Lindsay Mitchell
Welfare Commentator
ph/fx 04 562 7944
mob 021 132 5968
Contact Lindsay Mitchell:

Ph/fx 04 562 7944
mob 021 132 5968

Read Lindsay's Blog here.
This website intends to shine light on social security and welfare reform. The current welfare system is unsustainable economically, socially and morally. This site is also intended to be a resource for people interested in welfare reform. Please acknowledge the source of any material you use from this site. Thank you.
Other Information:
Maori & Welfare  and  Welfare & Crime
Need help to search Parliamentary Questions?
Many welfare models exist throughout the developed world.  New Zealand’s welfare system is unusual in two ways, firstly, because it is funded through general taxation. Secondly, [More...]